Showing posts with label Thomas Hofweber. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Thomas Hofweber. Show all posts

Tuesday, 17 November 2026

Two proponents of Idealism; Hofweber and Hawkins.

 There’s the story of the lost tourist in Ireland who asked:

  • How do I get to Ballina?

  • If I was you I wouldn’t start from here.


That’s the thing with Idealism of its several kinds, it’s where they start from.  Representations as the ingenious Thomas Hofweber does brings you into the arcane regions of the philosophy of language and the Scylla and Charibides of the ineffable and the effable.  The real in the sense of rocks and libraries continue to be out there but their reality is grasped by the mind which somehow makes the mind the centre of reality.  We won’t ever find anything which is not graspable by the mind.  That seems light touch Idealism.  


I’m still reading in it but I am unlikely to change my mind though it is stimulating. (Idealism and the Harmony of Thought and Reality)  


Nathan Hawkins lays out in a very lucid fashion his ‘facts’ which he construes, contrary to received opinion, as ‘true thoughts’.  Again the mental first foot.  You start as you mean to go on.  That doesn’t unrealise the rocks and the libraries but it does slacken the grip on ontology.  The basic question for me is: how does that out there, the object, come to be somehow in here in me as a subject, in its own reality, as it is.  Am I saying in so many words that my mind has captured it and that its capturability has my mind as its central condition.  You see what an iron mountain Hofweber is. 


Anyway the ball joint neck of the philosopher is designed to accomplish a universal swivel.


The Case for Idealism made by Nathan Hawkins:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7quW8AlngH0&t=1202s

Very interesting, very instructive, very lucid ,scholarly presentation. 

Hawkins on his channel also in dialogue with Hofweber on Mind as central to reality.