The power of the circulating library, Mudie’s in particular, could force the splitting of ‘the Woodlanders’ into 3 volumes even though the book is not very long, less than 400 pages. Moreover they enforced their strict Victorian morality which introduced a good deal of unreality into male female relationships. Hardy tries to bring some credible circumstances into the relation of Giles and Grace but the note of desperation is there. He doesn’t really believe it.
It’s a novel of counterparts. Winterbourne//Fitzpiers. Grace Melbury/Marty South. As usual in Hardy novels disappointment is a certainty. Rising beyond your class is doomed. Old Melbury has given an expensive education to his daughter but as you would expect this has left her ill at ease in the rural setting of the novel. He now considers that his promise to Winterborne which he will not go back on was slightly rash. He had virtually given his neighbour, a sturdy hardworking man the right to woo his daughter. Grace, as the philosopher remarked, lacks agency, and misses her chance to find a decent man through her insipidity and lack of resolve. She drifts between all the forces in her life. Clearly education for her was a spoiling factor.
The descriptions of the yearly cycle of the woodlanders is beautifully described as is the setting in which they work. The writing is as fine as anything in Hardy, nothing is forced. This is someone who knows his terrain and has lived it with the people. However the depression which dogged him unquestionably affected the life of his characters. Do not expect a happy ending.
The stratification of society is a theme very well delineated, one of the reasons why it is a classic. The characters are well realized as individuals not simply types. The writing is precise, compressed poetry. A very fine novel if only Mudie has kept his paws off it but that meta allowance is readily granted.